Elkanah
D. Edwards
Evander Childs H.S.
Like all countries thirty
degrees north and south of the equator, South East Asia is one
of the world's most beautiful tropical regions. From the air,
the continuous rolling hills that simply join one country to another
is a breathtaking experience. The natural greenery that seem to
manifest itself from the north, all the way to the south is a
contribution of the annual monsoon ram that remind us of what
the natural world should be like. Sadly, however, we are ever
mindful of the fact that such natural beauty will soon catalogued
on the endangered species list. The ever flowing, ever brown,
ever widening, ever used, Mekong River, is a gift of nature that
all creatures, great and small must experience. The calm blue
waters of the South China Sea extend an invitation to the believer
in the medicinal virtues of the seas that not even the greatest
of skeptics can resist. The cultural and historical richness that
have been left for ensuing generations to study and learn from,
makes South East Asia a school of a different kind - an open university.
The people
of Viet Nam were very friendly. From Hanoi in the North through
to Ho Chi Min City in the south, the people spoke very openly.
They approached with a willingness to befriend us. Usually, the
conversations began with the question - "where are you from?"
"America!" was all that was needed to get a smiling
conversation going. Many of our early encounters with local Vietnamese
were with children. Conversations that began as a solicitation
for a sale, would quickly turn into a desire to learn more about
America and us. I was impressed with the children's willingness
to talk about themselves and their families. At Halong Bay, eleven-year-old
Joe was very forth coming with information about himself and his
family. He was the fourth child in a family of eight children;
he was in the 5th grade, and was out on summer vacation- His reason
for being at this rest site was to raise money to pay for his
education when school reopened in September. At Danang, hundreds
of miles away, thirteen- year - old Lulu was just as forthcoming
with personal information.
Of great
interest, and I must add, surprise, was the ease with which some
of the local children were able to converse with us in English.
We teamed later that English is taught in some schools. However,
most children learn English by listening and conversing with the
English-speaking foreigners from Australia and elsewhere, who
visit Viet Nam as tourists and foreign-aid professionals.
Child labor is practiced
extensively in Viet Nam as well as in Cambodia, as a way of supplementing
the family income. At every tourist sight that we visited, children
made up a large percentage of the vendors. Lulu wanted me to buy
her souvenir cards - ten for one dollar, and would not stop following
me until I had made a purchase. I was pushed to make another and
another When asked why she was being so persistent, she replied
in, local Vietnamese, winch a female by-stander interpreted as,
"I need the money for school." Then in an even more
persistent tone, Lulu kept asking, "will you give me bible,
dollar for my coins?" At first it was very difficult to understand
what Lulu was asking. However, when Lulu's persistent request
was explained to me, especially when my unofficial interpreter
explained, I realized that the coins were not legal tenders at
the banks or local business houses. When I offered to take the
coins, the joys on her face made me think that I had offered her
"a piece of heaven". At that particular moment, it did
not even occur to me to ask her, how much it was, or how did she
come into 1 possession of so many US coins. Unfortunately, Lulu
did not get the US notes that she wanted because she was not able
to meet with me at the time and place we agreed to, and 1 was
leaving Hoi An at eight o'clock the following morning.
Another point of interest
was the ease with which some children conducted their sales transactions,
both in Dong and US currency. Most of the children were even able
to mentally calculate the value of their goods in dollars, when
the buyer insisted that he/she did not have Dong. Did they really
understand the rate of exchange? I seriously doubted, it, since
many times I was certain that the value of our purchases were
much more than the price we paid in dollars.
14,000 Dong=U.S. $1.00
Early on the trip, there
was the need to make a distinction between racist overtures and
simply curiosity. At the end of the trip, I hope that I was right
by, concluding that the experiences I had were not racism but
genuine curiosity on the part of maw people, with my color It
was obvious that many people were curious to see, someone of non-Asian
features as dark as me. Their behavior conveyed the impression
that, for the most part many ordinary Vietnamese had not had much
close contact with, people of African background. I refrain from
saying "black," because I did see dark skinned Asian
families from other parts of South East Asia who were also visiting
Vietnam This was also interesting, since color television was
visible in many homes. On several occasions during the trip, persons
would approach me just to touch, or compare their skin color with
mine. At restaurants, it was not unusual to be served extras by
female waitresses.
At a food market outside
of Ho Chi Min City, on our way from Dalat, a local female fanner
insisted that I eat along with her from a huge guava that she
had given to me. I counted at least three separate occasions when
ladies flattered me by telling me that I was a handsome man. I
was also complemented for having a lovely smile. It was not possible
to conclude that overtures such as these could be perceived as
acts of racism.
Another high point of
the trip was the interpretation the Vietnamese gave of the war.
Across the country, the war was referred to as "The American
War." One would have thought that because of the enormity
of our involvement in the war, and the pain we inflicted upon
the people, especially in the north, people would have been bitter
towards, and suspicious of us, Americans. This was not the case
People who spoke about the war did so with a smile on their faces.
They seemed to have accepted the war as a closed chapter in their
country's history. Some of our party, as well as local and foreign
intellectuals attribute this rather laissez-faire or simply indifferent
attitude towards the war to the age of the Vietnamese population.
More than fifty percent of Vietnamese are under the age of twenty-five,
meaning that most Vietnamese were not born at the time of the
war.
At the Museum of War
Crimes in Hanoi, the attitude of the local people was also rather
interesting. The large number of foreigners who were touring the
building' displayed a deep sense of reverence towards the photographs
and inscriptions on the walls, or in the secured glass cabinets.
However, for the local people who were also on' tour at the same
time, the atmosphere was less solemn. They talked and laughed
so uncaringly that in my opinion, it bordered closely to disrespect.
But then again, I was forced to ask, was I reading too much into
the behavior of the young, and seemingly' intelligent Vietnamese?
Could it be that my cognitive knowledge of the horrors of war'
was coloring my judgment of the people's behavior?
As we traveled through
the country, we were forced to define the term "poverty"'
in the context of the Viet Nam experience. In the homes of most
people, we saw a television set, a bed and eating utensils in
fair to good condition. It was not possible to conclude that plumbing
was a feature of every household. In fact, we entered homes that
were plumbed; but running water was not always available. Electric
cables were visible even in the most remote villages. The most
popular form of transportation was the motorcycle, which many
people owned; and those who did not ride the motorcycle, rode
a bicycle.
We did not see wide spread
begging in Vietnam; and, for large cities such as Hanoi, Hue and
Dalat, the people seemed very industrious. Many people do farming
as a way of life Others are local merchants and vendors who trade
in goods intended for the tourist market. The streets and sidewalks
were clean.

In spite of all the positives,
there were vestiges of poverty in all the communities we visited.
The rivers are polluted with human and animal waste. People use
the polluted waters for drinking and bathing, thus exposing large
sections of the population to various types of diseases such as
dysentery, diarrhea, and especially dengue fever. Foods are prepared
and sold with little regard for the observance of basic health
standards such as using clean hands, clean utensils, and covering
perishable foods or foods that cannot be washed, such as bread,
from flies and other disease carrying insects. The wages of teachers
and other civil servants are small in comparison to what we earn
here, in the United States.
A large section of the
population is peasant farmers. They still rely on the water buffalo
to plough the nee patties. Most farmers own very small plots of
land on which they cultivate every possible kind of food that
the family needs. Children are used as additional farm hands.
This compromises their early education and makes child labor a
potential problem for the country.
In Viet Nam, not once
did we engage in any discussion with our guide, lecturers, or
even the common people about the Cambodians. However, it was quite
the opposite while we were in Cambodia. Our Siem Reap guide never
ceased to educate us on the unfair treatment of the Vietnamese
people and government towards the Cambodians. According to our
guide, a sizeable portion of Cambodia's social and economic woes
must be attributed to the economic plundering and social maltreatment
of the Vietnamese upon the people of Cambodia. "The Vietnamese
soldiers raped the women and girls, while the government continues
to infringe of the boundary line of Cambodia."
Using the universal parameters
of what constitutes poverty, the people of Cambodia are poor.
In Siem Reap, we saw beggars - children and adults alike. There
were visible signs of malnourished children. There were less medical
facilities. There was not a proliferation of electric lines, as
we had seen earlier in Vietnam "Kris-crossing" the country.
People live in thatched houses with little or no electricity or
plumbing. There is much evidence of child labor practiced in Cambodia.
Unlike the Vietnamese,
the Cambodians never ceased revisiting the miseries of the war,
and its impact on their present situation. Unlike the Vietnamese,
the Cambodians make their poverty a daily conversation of self-pity.
This feeling of self-pity, and self-indulgences with the horrors
of the past, may do the Cambodians no good other than dwarf their
ability to make the future a positive experience for all of its
citizens.
As someone that grew
up and law worked in the Third World, I was very surprised at
the quality of education in Cambodia. The country does not enforce,
albeit, if it does have, a policy on universal primary education.
There are few school buildings in the country, and those that
we saw were caricature of the "old schoolhouse, used in the
United States over a century ago. Also, where there are school
buildings, we were told that they are not large enough to house
all the children of school age. As a result, children can only
attend school approximately two hours a day. The first group of
children must vacate the building to make room for the second
group.
Teachers are poorly paid, earning approximately $360.00 (US) annually.
To supplement their small earnings, teachers are forced to work
after school, perform noneducational tasks such as working in
hotels, bars and restaurant.
Wealthy parents employ
the some teachers to tutor their children privately On the other
hand, poor children and their parents raise money for education
by serving as local tour guides at temple cites such as at Angkor
Wat. Others become vendors for merchants located in the cities.
There are few teachers' colleges in Cambodia; only one in Siem
Reap. This college trains teachers to work throughout the country,
however, we learned that few of these teachers ever take up residence
in the rural communities. Rural communities are not economically
attractively places to work. It is more economically viable to
stay and work in the urban societies. The greatest benefit of
this is the opportunity to got additional employment that would
boost their meager monthly income.
Cambodia's present educational
deficiencies, and the plight of the Cambodian people, I had to
remind myself, are the direct result of one of its most infamous
sons- Pol Pot. Systemically, he killed every educated Cambodian,
young and old, under the pretext of purging the country of imperialist
sympathizers. This is a grim reminder to us all, that the demonic
behavior of men, such as Pol Pot, and Adolph Hitler, (and now,
even in more recent times Osama Bin Laden, his vicious attack
on innocent people inside the World Trade Center and the Pentagon)
must stop, and must never be repeated again.
There were positive things
in Cambodia. The ancient temples at Angkor Wat, their architecture,
inscriptions and motifs united us with a civilization long gone.
Our Siem Reap guide was thoroughly educated on the sites that
we were to visit For an ordinary tour guide, he seemed comfortable
with such disciplines as history, geography, archeology, and architecture
I often wondered how would our guide have handled the tour, in
terms of being so seemingly knowledgeable with the history and
archeology of Cambodia, if, for any reason, we were forced off
the designated path?
In Cambodia, we saw very
distinct social communities. We visited typical Third World villages.
Most of the houses in, rural, and even some houses in the urban
communities are wooden houses covered with thatched roofs. Apart
from the minority communities of the Northern minority hill tribes
that we visited in Viet Nara, it was not so easy to identify poor
versus middle-class Vietnamese. The distinction of social elm
in Cambodia is more pronounced. In Cambodia, we saw poor people
and we saw "not so poor people."
Although most Vietnamese
may admit to it, by and large, there is much' commonality between
the two neighbors. Both countries are poor - Cambodia more so'
than Vietnam Both have an agricultural economy, with Vietnam inching
faster towards mechanical farming. Both depend upon China and
the Chinese market for most of their goods and services.
Vietnam however, is able to make its own contribution to the global
economy by being a major rice producing country. The education
system in both countries has much' to be desired. Vietnam, nonetheless,
is providing more opportunities to educate its youth' than Cambodia
is presently doing, Suspicion and mistrust of each other's intentions
and behavior are characteristics of the relationship between both
countries. The Vietnamese avoidance of discussion of their neighbors
across the border serves only to confirm that all is not well
between these two peoples.
Hazel must be complemented
and thanked for the intense, thoughtful, and dedicated planning
that went into the preparation process prior to leaving for South
East Asia. Her choice of professors to prepare us for the trip
was excellent. Each presentation was followed by academically
stimulating discussions. The professors did what they were asked
to do - introduce the world of South East Asia in an interesting,
stimulating way. In South East Asia, when it would appear that
the local professors, whom Hazel did not know nor choose, would
quell that yearning desire that we were all over taken by, Hazel
revitalized the moment by making important comments, or asking
pointed questions. The trip would not have been the success that
it has been had any of those sessions been anything less than
they were.
Of equally
great importance was the debriefing institute held from August
21 thru 24. This session allowed each participant to reflect on
the region we had just visited, and to continue the process of
developing appropriate lessons to suit the needs of our students.
I think that I speak for all of us when I say, "the sessions
allowed us to make sense of our experiences as well as understand
those of the young American men and women who sacrificed their
lives in those distant lands so far from home. We will all have
much to teach for many years to come."